North-South divide?

Back in 2007, Danny Dorling of the University of Sheffield wrote a piece on the nature and geographical extent of the so-called North-South divide in Britain. This was nothing new: as most of us already knew, the north-south socio-economic divide was not simply a matter of drawing a horizontal line through Watford, nor was it a case of delineating the southern boundaries of Yorkshire, Lancashire and Cheshire. Rather, it was more complex – a meandering line between the River Severn to the southwest and the Humber to the northeast.

According to Professor Dorling, the transition from north to south is not as gradual as one might expect, and shows little sign of that psychogeographic favourite, a borderline ‘zone of liminality’. The imagined divide is, in fact, a fractal line sharply defined by all manner of factors – voting patterns, house prices, wealth, health (average life expectancy is a year less north of the line), life chances, Oxbridge university access, language – particularly vowel sounds – and even preferences for flat or sparkled beer. Of course, the line roughly follows distinct features of physical geography too – the division between upland and lowland Britain, and pastoral and arable farming – features that have stongly influenced British history and culture. The divide also delineates the territory colonised by Saxon invaders and follows uncannily close to the route traced by the Roman Fosse Way.

I was reminded of this theoretical divide twice this week. First, by an article in the Big Issue written by Professor Dorling to accompany a feature on George Orwell and then by a BBC Radio 4 programme, the second part of a documentary called North and South: Across the Great Divide presented by Ian Marchant, in which the writer travelled to various places either side of this imaginary line to investigate what local people thought of the notion.

What was pleasing was that Marchant looked closely at some of my own old stomping grounds. I was born in Stourbridge in the West Midlands and grew up in Redditch, a small town just north of the divide that became a new (and suddenly much larger) town just before I left (and which earned the dubious honour of once being dubbed ‘the most boring place in the known universe’). Marchant interviewed people in Henley-in-Arden, a posh, leafy Tudor-beamed town that lies just south of Redditch across the north-south frontier in Warwickshire. The view of the Henleyites was that people from Redditch tended to be more common, while that of the Redditchers was that they would love to live in Henley given half the chance but they simply could not afford to. Hardly groundbreaking stuff but, certainly, growing up in workaday Redditch, places like Henley – and Stratford upon Avon and Warwick – did seem to belong to another, altogether more glamorous world despite their relative proximity. But then, so did Worcester (which actually lies north of the line) and even some parts of Birmingham.

If this north-south orientation is correct then, having journeyed east and slightly north in adult life to move to Norwich from the West Midlands, I have actually crossed the divide – the Tudor line, as Dorling sometimes calls it – southwards. A geographical paradox perhaps – West Midlands to East Anglia, sort of north to kind of south. I still say bath not ‘barth’ but, there again, I do prefer my ale unsparkled.

Marchant ended the program in Gloucestershire’s Forest of Dean, a small but very distinct enclave, squeezed between the Severn and Wye, which stands at the most southerly ‘northern’ point of this cultural divide. I used to know this area quite well and was always impressed by its strong sense of place, wilful isolationism and warm-hearted yet tough natives. To me it always seemed somehow closer to the spirit of South Wales than to the rest of Gloucestershire. Despite having the same latitude as Watford, with working-class forestry and mining traditions, and hardly a trace of tweeness in its villages, there are plenty of stereotypical ‘northern’ characteristics on display here. The ‘Forest’, as natives always call it,  really does seem a very different place compared to the opulent sandstone villages of the Gloucestershire Cotswolds just across the River Severn.

In essence, the BBC4 programme is as much about social class as it is about geography but it raises some interesting points. You can listen again here. For a very different point of view, you can read what Simon Jenkins makes of Dorling’s analysis here. The fact that he scathingly dismisses the Sheffield professor as ‘geographer royal by appointment to the left’ might give you some idea as to what to expect.

About East of Elveden

Hidden places, secret histories and unsung geography from the east of England and beyond
This entry was posted in Human Geography and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to North-South divide?

  1. Dave says:

    Interesting post Laurence. As an Irishman the social divide in Britain has always fascinated and baffled me in equal measure, ever since reading the road to Wigan Pier in my teens when I swallowed everything Orwell wrote. I have to wonder in today’s Britain how much of the divide is related to immigration though? The Economist this week pointed to the fact that while foreign language learning is dropping rapidly in Britain as a whole, 50% of children attending schools in Central London speak a language other than English at home. I’m guessing not many of them drink ale of any variety though.

    BTW I have been meaning to ask you for a while, where is the photo in your banner from?

  2. Thanks for your comments Dave. I don’t know about recent immigration but certainly in the past, in the era of post-colonial migration, there was large-scale immigration on either side of the line. Birmingham, for example, used to have a larger percentage of ethnic minorities in its total population than London, as did Bradford. I don’t know if this is still the case though. There’s an internal migration too as well – the well-educated moving south to job opportunities in the southeast. Its a complex issue and I’m no expert.

    The photo in the banner shows the striated chalk and carstone cliffs at Old Hunstanton, Norfolk, which, curiously for East Anglia, actually face west across The Wash.

  3. dianajhale says:

    Thanks for bringing the programme to my attention. I shall listen. I feel an affinity with this issue in having lived both North and South and also being half Welsh and half English and can think of many examples to support the existence of a divide. I see the whole of Wales (and of course Scotland) is in the North according to Professor Dorling’s map. I always want to support the underdog so do often feel guilty from even being a Londoner currently (but also by birth)! I do support the possibility of having multiple identities and affinities.
    I think the immigrant factor is a separate thing really as it adds another whole dimension and certainly applies to the whole country not just London, as well as historically. That is more an urban /rural divide maybe, although even that is not true with agricultural labourers mainly being immigrants these days. This is getting too complicated but thanks for the interesting post!

  4. Hi Diana. Like you, I support the possibility of having multiple identities. In fact, I think this is essential in modern Britain where, in theory at least, there is always the potential to transcend both geography and class. What interests me is whether the north-south divide more entrenched now than, say, back in the seemingly more meritocratic 1960s. As you rightly point out, the divide is a very complicated matter.

  5. dobraszczyk says:

    Really interesting post. Over the summer, I drove from Stockport to Norwich and remembered the feeling just after Newark-on-Trent of having crossed into some richer land, even though I had no idea beforehand of this imaginary line. There are lots of anomalies though in the general picture – enclaves of wealth in the East Riding, the Yorkshire Dales, Derbyshire Peak District and Cheshire; and, of course, poverty in the south – parts of West Cornwall, Hastings and bits of Essex and Kent. I guess it’s the sense of what dominates geographically that provides the general view in any given part of the country.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s